Industry Guide · 16 of 16 chapters published
An insurance agency bids against carriers with national budgets, lead sellers that can pass one shopper to several agents, and comparison sites advertising car insurance at $29 a month. One agency may sell auto, home, life, commercial and Medicare coverage, each with its own buyers, prices and rules. These sixteen chapters build a Google Ads account in the order we build them, using real searches, websites, ads and customer reviews from one example market, the Cleveland-Akron area. Your numbers will differ. The method works for independent and captive agencies anywhere in the US.
The whole guide in five steps. Numbers come from eleven sample agencies around Cleveland and Akron, their ads and client reviews, and Keyword Planner's US data. Yours will differ; the method won't.
Count texts, calls of 30 seconds or more and quote forms, each quote request once. Send the bound policy back through enhanced conversions for leads, or by click ID alone for Medicare and SR-22, valued at the commission you earn, not the premium.
Then price the household, not the car. In J.D. Power's study, 45% of auto shoppers already had a homeowners policy but only 20% got a home quote. And 52 of 144 agency complaints we read describe a callback that never came.
Give every line its own ad group and page: five of the 11 sites run separate quote forms by line. Keep carrier names and logins out, launch in exact match, and bid each line by hand from what a client is worth, worked back through your close rate.
Write the ads from your reviews. Carriers lead with savings, but none of the 65 local and captive agency ads we read showed a price, and agency reviews praise the agent who shopped around and called back.
Target only the states where you hold a license and set location to Presence. Switch search partners, the Display Network, AI Max and text customization off at launch. Keep auto-tagging and call reporting on, and give your agency name a campaign of its own.
Exploration, broad match with a target CPA, opens once Isolation brings about 30 quality conversions a month, usually months two or three. Performance Max usually follows in months six or seven, once that pace holds with both Search campaigns running, with your agency name excluded.
Local Services Ads take agencies only in California and Florida, so everywhere else the map listing does that job. Demand Gen reaches people about to buy a home. AI Max goes on last, as an experiment, with words like "free" blocked for Medicare.
Medicare ads need Google's health insurance certification, which starts with an outside verifier, G2RS. Searches for Medicare Advantage plans ran four times higher in October than in June, so start by summer, and record every Medicare sales call.
A captive agent's first approval comes from the carrier: none of the five local State Farm agents we found advertising ran the ads from an account in their own name. Commercial lines get a campaign and a daily budget of their own, since car insurance searches outnumber business insurance nearly 14 to 1.
New account? Chapter 1 comes first. Each chapter uses the setup from the ones before it.
Count every call and quote request, then send back the policies you bound and what they pay
One ad group per line of coverage, bids set by hand, and ads written from what customers praise
The Google defaults to change, and the states your license covers, before the first click
Wider campaigns once Search shows which policies sell
Bonus chapters: Medicare ads, captive agents and commercial lines
The order matters as much as the campaigns. Each step waits until the one before it has taught Google something.
Exact match on the quote and agent searches you know turn into policies, plus your agency name in a campaign of its own.
Broad match with a target CPA once the account logs about 30 quality conversions a month. Busier accounts get there sooner.
The usual pace, not the rule. It waits for about 30 quality conversions a month, held steady.
Video for people about to buy a home, Local Services Ads tested in the two states that offer them to agencies, and AI Max last, with Medicare wording fenced in.
Read in order. Sending the bound policy back to Google comes before the first keyword.
Chapter 01 →Read the captive agent chapter first. Your carrier's rules come before any Google setting.
Chapter 15 →Examples come from insurance agencies around Cleveland, Akron and Canton, described as we found them. Your numbers will differ; the method is the same.
Chapter 05 →Google Ads for Insurance Agencies
We've run paid ads for 25+ years and seen just about every way a budget goes sideways. Get on the phone with someone who does this every day. Bring your questions, your numbers and your skepticism. You'll hang up knowing what we'd do, whether you hire us or not.
Or see how our Google Ads management works.